Where to Find the Best Cookie Cutters and Decorations in Chicago

Jan 31, 2026By TopTier Solutions
TopTier Solutions

Discovering Unique Cookie Cutters in Chicago

Chicago, a city known for its vibrant culture and diverse neighborhoods, is also home to some of the best places to find cookie cutters and decorations. Whether you're a professional baker or a home enthusiast, you'll find plenty of options to fuel your creativity. Let's explore some of the top spots in the Windy City.

cookie cutters

Local Shops with a Personal Touch

Nothing beats the charm of a local boutique when it comes to finding unique cookie cutters. Shops like The Chopping Block in Lincoln Square offer a wide variety of baking tools, including cookie cutters in fun and creative shapes. These stores often carry items you won't find in big-box retailers, making them perfect for those seeking something special.

Another must-visit is the Downtown Cookie Co. in the Loop. Known for its vast selection of cookie decorations, this shop provides personalized advice to help you choose the perfect tools for your baking projects.

Craft Stores with Baking Sections

For those who prefer a one-stop-shop experience, craft stores like Michaels and Joann Fabrics have extensive baking sections. Here, you can find a variety of cookie cutters and decorations alongside other baking essentials. Their seasonal collections ensure that you’ll always find the perfect item for any holiday or special occasion.

craft store

Exploring Gourmet Baking Shops

If you're looking for high-end baking supplies, Chicago's gourmet shops are the place to go. Stores like Sur La Table offer premium cookie cutters and decorations that appeal to both amateurs and seasoned bakers. These shops often host workshops, giving you the chance to learn new techniques and make the most of your tools.

Also, consider visiting Eataly in River North, where you can find exquisite baking tools and decorations. The store's culinary experts are always on hand to provide tips and inspiration.

Online Options with Local Pickup

For those who prefer shopping online, several local stores offer convenient online ordering with in-store pickup. This option allows you to browse their selection from the comfort of your home and collect your items when it's convenient for you. Check out websites of local favorites like Baker's Dozen and get access to their exclusive collections.

online shopping

Seasonal Markets and Pop-Ups

Don’t miss out on Chicago’s seasonal markets and pop-up shops, which frequently feature local artisans selling handmade cookie cutters and decorations. The Randolph Street Market and Christkindlmarket are just a couple of events where you can find unique, locally-crafted items.

These venues not only provide an opportunity to discover new baking tools but also support local artists and small businesses.

Conclusion

Whether you’re searching for a quirky cookie cutter or elegant decorations, Chicago offers an abundance of options to suit your needs. From charming local shops to bustling craft stores and gourmet retailers, the city’s diverse offerings ensure that every baker finds exactly what they’re looking for.